Roof Replacement Cost By Material Types | Compare Options

When considering a roof replacement cost there are a variety of factors to think about. A major one is the cost of the materials used.

Do you want to improve the look and value of your home?

A roof replacement is a great investment guaranteed to boost your home’s curb appeal while protecting your home from the elements. A quality roof will last your years with little or no maintenance required.






The roof replacement cost often causes people to hesitate before replacing their roof. Roof replacements are a major project that costs time and money. For some, that means a roof replacement must be expensive.

Cut Roof Replacement Cost

Fortunately, this isn’t always true! Researching the cost to replace a roof by material type will give you insight into the best roofing options to fit your roofing needs. Here’s what you need to know about the roof replacement cost and the best materials for your home’s roof!

Asphalt Shingle Roof Costs

Asphalt shingles are one of the most popular and affordable roof replacement materials available. Even though more roofing options are becoming widely available, most Americans choose asphalt over other roofing materials.

Asphalt shingles are durable, aesthetically pleasing, and affordable, averaging anywhere from $3 to $5 per square foot. They’re easy to install which helps homeowners save on labor costs.

Asphalt shingles consist of a top layer of asphalt topped with ceramic granules. Below, the asphalt adheres to a felt paper or fiberglass base. Shingles with a fiberglass base are lighter and offer more durability and protection.

You’ll find a nearly endless selection of asphalt shingle colors designed to match any home or style. There are three main types of shingles to choose from:

  • 3-tab shingles are the most affordable option offering a clean rectangular pattern
  • Dimensional shingles have two bonded layers and create a 3D appearance
  • Luxury shingles have a multi-dimensional appearance, optimum durability, and replicate the look of high-end slate or cedar shake roofs

Your budget and home’s style will help you decide which type of roof replacement asphalt shingle works best for you.

Concrete Tile Roof Costs

Concrete tile roofs mimic the look of clay and ceramic roof tiles. The advantage of concrete over clay is concrete is more affordable and often weighs less.

The average cost of concrete tile, including labor, is around $3 to $5 per square foot. Concrete tile is easier to install compared to clay roofing which will help cut labor costs. Today’s concrete tiles have interlocking designs to reinforce their strength while making installation easier.

A concrete replacement roof offers more benefits than just cutting costs, such as:

  • Longer lifespan than other roofing materials
  • Greater durability and strength
  • Easy to maintain
  • Come in a variety of colors and styles
  • Resistant to rot and insects
  • Fire resistant

While concrete tile roofing materials will cost more than metal or asphalt shingles, concrete tile will improve the value and look of your home.

Metal Roof Costs

Metal roofing comes in many shapes and styles. You can find metal shingles as well as long metal sheets. The most common metals used are steel and aluminum with higher-end metal roofing containing a stone coating.

Metal roofing costs between $8 to $15 depending on the type of material and any additional features. While considered a premium roofing material, metal roofing is affordable and can last for up to 50 years with proper care. This roofing material is ideal for any climate and any homeowner who doesn’t want a roof requiring a lot of maintenance.

Metal roofing is gaining popularity in the green building industry. Most metal roofs consist of recycled materials and help keep building cool in the warmer months. Opting for a metal roof replacement will cut energy costs.

Like shingles, most metal roofing styles are lightweight and easy to install. Labor costs will be lower as the metal will be easier to maneuver and attach to your home’s roof.

Wood Shake Roof Costs

Wood shake is a gorgeous roofing material made from natural hardwood cedar. Other popular wood materials that can affect the price include redwood, cypress, and pine. Wood shake a traditional roofing option that people have been using on their houses for hundreds of years.

Wood shake roofing comes with a hefty price tag compared to the other roofing materials on this list. Wood shake with installation costs about $6 to $8 per square foot. If you have a 3,000 square foot roof, expect to pay close to $18,000 for a full wood shake roof replacement.

The advantages of using wood shake include:

  • Greater insulation to cut energy costs year-round
  • Strong and durable in all weather conditions
  • Pest and UV resistant
  • Aesthetically pleasing

Wood shake does require a roof replacement and maintenance every ten years or so as the wood does deteriorate faster than other materials on this list.

You can make your wood shake roofing last longer by choosing a composite wood shake. This is a synthetic material designed to last longer, offer greater durability, and require less maintenance.

Composite shake costs about the same as traditional wood shake materials.

Other Factors Affecting Roof Replacement Cost

The material you choose will have the greatest impact on your roof replacement cost. There are, however, other roofing aspects that will influence this cost such as the size of your roof, labor costs, and more. Knowing about these hidden costs will prepare you for any surprising costs that come your way.

Size of Your Roof

A larger roof will require more materials and therefore will cost more. When requesting a roofing estimate, have a professional measure your roof and offer you a quote after assessing your roof in-person.

Roof Pitch

Steeper roofs are more challenging to work on and pose a greater risk of injury. They also have a larger surface area than flatter roofs which will also increase your roofing costs.

Removal of the Old Roof

Most roofers will need the old roof removed to start installing the new roof. Ask about roof removal costs when your meet with a roofing professional.

Pick the Best Materials for Your Roof Replacement Today

Finding your roof replacement cost doesn’t have to be a stressful process. By taking a moment to research the materials available, you can find the perfect roof for your home. Not only will it look great but it will fit your budget.

Does your home need a roof replacement? Request a Quote! We’re happy to connect you with one of our many talented roofing professionals today.